Handcrafted Toffee Made with Love
Indulge in our premium butter toffee, carefully crafted in small batches using only the finest ingredients. Available in rich dark chocolate and milk chocolate varieties.
Our Artisan Process
Handcrafted Quality
Each batch made with care and attention to detail
Perfect Pairings
Delicious with coffee, tea, dessert or enjoyed on its own
Premium Packaging
Beautiful presentation perfect for gifting
Our Signature Toffee
Dark Chocolate Butter Toffee (2 oz)
Rich butter toffee covered in decadent dark chocolate. A sophisticated treat for chocolate lovers.
Dark Chocolate Butter Toffee (4 oz)
Rich butter toffee covered in decadent dark chocolate. Perfect for intense chocolate flavor.
Dark Chocolate Butter Toffee (1/2 lb)
Rich butter toffee covered in decadent dark chocolate. Ideal for special occasions.
Milk Chocolate Butter Toffee (2 oz)
Our signature butter toffee covered in premium milk chocolate. Perfect for a sweet treat or …
Milk Chocolate Butter Toffee (4 oz)
Our signature butter toffee covered in premium milk chocolate. Perfect for sharing.
Milk Chocolate Butter Toffee (1/2 lb)
Our signature butter toffee covered in premium milk chocolate. Great for parties or gifts.
About Colleen's Toffee
For many years, Colleen has been perfecting the art of toffee making, creating each batch with the same care and attention as if it were for her own family.
Using traditional recipes and premium ingredients, every piece of our toffee is hand-crafted in small batches to ensure the perfect balance of buttery richness and satisfying crunch. Whether you prefer our signature dark chocolate or the smooth milk chocolate variety, each bite delivers an unforgettable experience.
Made with Love
Premium Quality
Ready to Treat Yourself?
Order online for pickup or delivery. Perfect for gifts, special occasions, or just because!
Start ShoppingLarge Orders Welcome!
Planning a special event or need toffee for your business? We welcome large orders! We've successfully fulfilled orders as large as 500 bags.
For large orders, please reach out with your order amount and time frame to ensure we can accommodate your needs and shipping deadline.
Contact Us for Large Orders