Handcrafted Toffee Made with Love

Indulge in our premium butter toffee, carefully crafted in small batches using only the finest ingredients. Available in rich dark chocolate and milk chocolate varieties.

Order Now Learn More
Colleen's Fresh Toffee

What Our Customers Say

Kimberly L.

My family did not like toffee until we had the gift of Colleen's Toffee, now I have to hide it. If you haven't tried it, you need to!

Yvonne S.

If you haven't tried this Toffee you're missing out. It's so good!

Rosanna R.

What luck! I ran into this lady this morning at Walmart, her basket was full of chocolate bars, butter... me being noisy I asked her what she was making? I ended up waiting for her to check out and I followed her to her car..I bought the most amazing bag of Colleen's Toffee!

Laurie A.

Delicious snack. Great price and fast shipping.

Ken P.

I received my bag, and had to stop myself from eating the whole thing in one sitting! It was everything a high quality confection should be. Each piece practically melted in my mouth. The flavor was just the right amount of sweet without being over powering. Crunchy, but somehow buttery smooth, every bite was perfection. If a sweet treat can be Heaven on Earth, this was as close as it gets!

Kimberly L.

My family did not like toffee until we had the gift of Colleen's Toffee, now I have to hide it. If you haven't tried it, you need to!

Yvonne S.

If you haven't tried this Toffee you're missing out. It's so good!

Rosanna R.

What luck! I ran into this lady this morning at Walmart, her basket was full of chocolate bars, butter... me being noisy I asked her what she was making? I ended up waiting for her to check out and I followed her to her car..I bought the most amazing bag of Colleen's Toffee!

Laurie A.

Delicious snack. Great price and fast shipping.

Ken P.

I received my bag, and had to stop myself from eating the whole thing in one sitting! It was everything a high quality confection should be. Each piece practically melted in my mouth. The flavor was just the right amount of sweet without being over powering. Crunchy, but somehow buttery smooth, every bite was perfection. If a sweet treat can be Heaven on Earth, this was as close as it gets!

Kimberly L.

My family did not like toffee until we had the gift of Colleen's Toffee, now I have to hide it. If you haven't tried it, you need to!

Yvonne S.

If you haven't tried this Toffee you're missing out. It's so good!

Rosanna R.

What luck! I ran into this lady this morning at Walmart, her basket was full of chocolate bars, butter... me being noisy I asked her what she was making? I ended up waiting for her to check out and I followed her to her car..I bought the most amazing bag of Colleen's Toffee!

Laurie A.

Delicious snack. Great price and fast shipping.

Ken P.

I received my bag, and had to stop myself from eating the whole thing in one sitting! It was everything a high quality confection should be. Each piece practically melted in my mouth. The flavor was just the right amount of sweet without being over powering. Crunchy, but somehow buttery smooth, every bite was perfection. If a sweet treat can be Heaven on Earth, this was as close as it gets!

5 customer reviews

Our Artisan Process

Handcrafted Quality
Handcrafted Quality

Each batch made with care and attention to detail

Perfect Pairings
Perfect Pairings

Delicious with coffee, tea, dessert or enjoyed on its own

Premium Packaging
Premium Packaging

Beautiful presentation perfect for gifting

Our Signature Toffee

Dark Chocolate Butter Toffee (2 oz)
Dark Chocolate Butter Toffee (2 oz)

Rich butter toffee covered in decadent dark chocolate. A sophisticated treat for chocolate lovers.

$5.00
Dark Chocolate Butter Toffee (4 oz)
Dark Chocolate Butter Toffee (4 oz)

Rich butter toffee covered in decadent dark chocolate. Perfect for intense chocolate flavor.

$8.00
Dark Chocolate Butter Toffee (1/2 lb)
Dark Chocolate Butter Toffee (1/2 lb)

Rich butter toffee covered in decadent dark chocolate. Ideal for special occasions.

$15.00
Milk Chocolate Butter Toffee (2 oz)
Milk Chocolate Butter Toffee (2 oz)

Our signature butter toffee covered in premium milk chocolate. Perfect for a sweet treat or …

$5.00
Milk Chocolate Butter Toffee (4 oz)
Milk Chocolate Butter Toffee (4 oz)

Our signature butter toffee covered in premium milk chocolate. Perfect for sharing.

$8.00
Milk Chocolate Butter Toffee (1/2 lb)
Milk Chocolate Butter Toffee (1/2 lb)

Our signature butter toffee covered in premium milk chocolate. Great for parties or gifts.

$15.00
View All Products
Colleen's Toffee Lifestyle

About Colleen's Toffee

For many years, Colleen has been perfecting the art of toffee making, creating each batch with the same care and attention as if it were for her own family.

Using traditional recipes and premium ingredients, every piece of our toffee is hand-crafted in small batches to ensure the perfect balance of buttery richness and satisfying crunch. Whether you prefer our signature dark chocolate or the smooth milk chocolate variety, each bite delivers an unforgettable experience.

Made with Love
Premium Quality

Ready to Treat Yourself?

Order online for pickup or delivery. Perfect for gifts, special occasions, or just because!

Start Shopping

Large Orders Welcome!

Planning a special event or need toffee for your business? We welcome large orders! We've successfully fulfilled orders as large as 1500 bags.

For large orders, please reach out with your order amount and time frame to ensure we can accommodate your needs and shipping deadline.

Contact Us for Large Orders